Loading:

  • Deep Sky Colors
  • astrophotography
  • stars
  • tools
  • books

Forum

Final notes after t...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Final notes after testing DSPX on five targets (OSC + dual-band)

2 Posts
2 Users
0 Reactions
139 Views
(@sergiusz)
Eminent Member
Joined: 2 months ago
Posts: 12
Topic starter   [#3371]

Hi Rogelio,

Thank you for the very quick replies to my earlier reports. Your diagnosis of the update problem was right: after I added the DSPX folders to the Norton exclusions, the in-app update from Beta 10 to Beta 11 installed without any problem.

I have now finished my test. Setup: Askar 400 at 280 mm, Player One Ares-C PRO (OSC), NINA, dual-band filters (Optolong L-eNhance and L-Ultimate). Targets: M31, IC 5070, NGC 6992, NGC 6888 and NGC 7000, all processed in DSPX from raw frames to the final signed image. The last target, NGC 7000 (114 × 180 s), was done in Beta 11 together with RC Astro’s tools.

What I liked most

Pre-processing is fast and transparent. Calibration, registration, integration, autocrop and plate solve for 114 frames took 58 seconds. Frame Selection with the charts, and the list of left-out frames with the reason for each, make it easy to see what is going on.
Background Neutralization with a region of interest. On NGC 7000, where the nebula fills almost the whole frame, I chose a reference area in a clean corner and got a perfectly neutral background.
Curves, Local Contrast and Histogram all have good live previews and behave predictably.
LaunchPads. I built my own narrowband and broadband pads with my tools in processing order. Import PixInsight launchpads is a nice touch for people coming from PI.
RC Astro integration works seamlessly. BlurXTerminator, NoiseXTerminator and StarXTerminator appeared as normal processes after allowing the CLI tool, and I could add them to my LaunchPad. The SHA-256 approval is a good idea.
Deep Star Removal is very good for a built-in free model.

Built-in tools compared with RC Astro on NGC 7000 (same image, similar settings, measured on the files)

Noise Reduction vs NoiseXTerminator: NXT left about 30% less luminance noise and about 2.5× less chroma noise. Detail was preserved in both. DSPX NR left fine colour “worms” in the background.
Deep Star Removal vs StarXTerminator: residual star peaks were 2686 for DSR and 990 for SXT (out of about 25,800 in the original). Both look fine on the nebula; SXT is a little cleaner on the background.

Issues still open in Beta 10/11

Noise Reduction does not clamp negative values. Reproduced in Beta 10: −0.0018 on NGC 6992, −0.0148 on NGC 6888. Beta 10 warns about out-of-range samples when the file is opened, but NR still writes them.
Deep Star Removal fails on drizzled (2×) images. My workaround was Integer Resample −2, then DSR, then resample ×2 and PixelMath.
Star Recombination silently does nothing if “Applies to” points to the wrong image. A warning would help.
Default frame weights (SNR estimate) gave poor results on my data. PSF signal weight worked well every time. Perhaps it would be a better default.
The status-bar estimate is not refreshed after Leave Out. It still says 120 frames when only 114 are used (still in Beta 11).
Frame selection reporting: “59 within limits” without naming the frames, a frame flagged with trails was chosen as the registration reference, and “0 built, 3 reused” is confusing when the masters come from the shared cache.
Curves keeps the previous curve when reopened, so I had to remember to press Reset each time.
No processing history is stored in the saved files.
Window handling: double-clicking the title bar does not restore a maximized image window (Cascade works). After Ctrl+Z the title still shows the last saved file name, which can lead to accidentally overwriting a file with Ctrl+S. Showing the last step or an “undone” state would help.
Arcsinh with Protect highlights scaled my image by 0.63, so the brightest pixel was at about 0.63 and I had to set Highlights in Histogram to 0.64 to use the full range. Maybe the log or the Histogram could suggest this.

Overall, DSPX has been a pleasure to use. The results on M31 and NGC 7000 are among my best images, and the way you respond to user feedback is exceptional. Thank you, and good luck with the release!

I have decided to buy a license.

Best regards,
Sergiusz



   
Quote
RBA
 RBA
(@rba)
Member Admin
Joined: 4 years ago
Posts: 22
 

Hi Sergiusz,
As always, thank you for your detailed report! I will be looking at all the unresolved issues, one by one, and report once they're all addressed.
Thanks again!!
RBA



   
ReplyQuote
Share:
This website uses cookies to improve your experience. Cookie Policy